How Parents Can Protect Their Children From the Toxic Race of School Grades
Our blog “The Trap of Validation – Why the ‘6’ Doesn’t Define the Genius” hit a nerve. Many parents reached out and said: “I see exactly what you described – the unfair competition, the ranking before they’re even adults – but what can I do for my child now?” This follow‑up is for you. It’s about how to talk to your 7–12‑year‑old and how to build a home where your child is never reduced to a number.
1. Explain the System in Your Child’s Language: “It’s Not a Measure of How Smart You Are”
Before you talk about homework or effort, your child needs to understand what school actually is. Not in adult theory, but in words they can feel.
Here’s how you might say it to a 7–12‑year‑old:
“Listen, I want to explain something important about school.
School is something adults invented to help children learn things and to decide who can go to which next class or school. It’s like a big machine that sorts people into groups.
That means something very important:
- It is not a machine that can tell how smart you really are.
- It is not a machine that can tell how good you are as a person.
When you do a test, it only shows what you remembered on that one day, in that one subject, with those questions. If you were tired, nervous, or had a bad day, the test doesn’t know that. It just gives a number.
So when you see a 5 or a 9, remember:
‘This number only tells me how I did on this test today.
It does not tell me how smart I really am.
It does not tell me how good I am as a person.’
Imagine someone has to run very fast in a race. One child wins. Does that mean they are smarter than the others? No. It only means they can run faster. It’s the same with school tests. They don’t see how kind you are, how funny you are, how good you are at building things, how brave you are, or how you help other people. Those things are also part of being smart and strong.”
End with this simple line your child can repeat:
2. Break the Race Illusion: “You’re Not Running Against Anyone”
School constantly compares: top 10, class average, “best” and “worst.” Children quickly feel they’re in a never‑ending race against everyone else.
You can say:
“At school, people like to ask: ‘Who got the highest?’ or ‘Who is the smartest in the class?’ It can feel like you are all running in a race against each other.
I want you to know something: in real life, you are not running against anyone else.
- Your brain is different from other brains.
- Your way of learning is different.
- What you will do in life is different.
So when you look at your grade, don’t think, ‘I am worse than that child’ or ‘I am better than that child.’ Think, ‘This is one result for me. I can learn from it, I can get help, I can improve. But it does not decide my future, and it does not decide my value.’”
You are quietly teaching your child: life is a journey, not a race against their classmates.
3. Separate Your Love From the Grade: Your Face Must Not Change With the Number
The system already ties worth to numbers. If you do the same at home, your child has nowhere safe. They will believe: “I am more loved when my number is higher.”
Watch your own reactions:
- Do you smile, praise, and give more attention only when the grade is high?
- Do you become cold, distant, or angry when the grade is low?
Your child is reading your face more than the report card. Make this your rule:
Practical approach:
- Focus on effort and honesty: “Did you try? Did you ask for help?”
- After a poor result: “These numbers are not what we want, but they do not decide who you are. We will look at your habits together. The number can change; your value doesn’t.”
- After a good result: Praise the process, not the label – “You worked hard and it shows,” instead of, “See, now you are smart.”
4. Refuse Comparisons at Home: No Sibling, No Classmate, No Clone
School lives on comparison. Home must not. Avoid phrases like:
- “Look at your sister’s marks…”
- “Your cousin already did this…”
- “The neighbor’s child is top of the class.”
Instead, anchor everything in your child’s own journey:
- “Last term you found this very hard. Now you improved. That’s what matters for you.”
- “We are not trying to make you like anyone else. We are helping you grow.”
- “You are not your brother/sister. You have your own path.”
Each person is special in their own way. The system compares; you must protect individuality.
5. Create a Parallel Report Card for Who They Are (Not Just What They Score)
If the only “report” your child sees is the school report, their world shrinks to what school values. Build a second, invisible report card at home that tracks what school does not measure.
Once a term, talk about things like:
- Kindness: “When did you help someone without being asked?”
- Honesty: “Did you tell the truth even when it was hard?”
- Curiosity: “What new thing did you get interested in this term?”
- Courage: “When did you try something that scared you or admit you didn’t understand?”
- Creativity / hands-on skills: “What did you build, draw, fix, or imagine?”
You can write this as a list, draw smiley faces, or simply talk. The form doesn’t matter; the message does:
6. Teach Them to Use the System Without Worshipping It
We can be honest: grades do open some doors in this world. Ignoring them completely can hurt your child’s options. The key is to show your child that school is a tool – not a god.
You can say:
“We will do our best in this system, because some chances still depend on these numbers. But we never confuse your grade with your future or your value.
If one door closes, there are other doors. There are many ways to build a good life — through school, through work, through skills, through creativity.”
Practically, help them:
- Study smarter (small blocks, practice questions, asking teachers for clarity).
- Keep boundaries: no sacrificing sleep, health, or basic joy for 0.5 more on a report.
- See other paths: vocational skills, arts, trades, entrepreneurship, helping professions.
7. Protect Their Mental Health When Pressure Peaks
Exams and report cards are where the pressure becomes visible: tears, stomach aches, “I am stupid,” “If I don’t get X, it’s over.”
Cushion this by:
- Setting expectations: “I expect honest effort, not perfection.”
- Normalizing mistakes: share one real story where you failed an exam or missed an opportunity and still found your way.
- Guarding basics: insist on enough sleep, breaks, and some play or movement.
- Listening for red flags: if your child links their worth or right to exist to a grade, stop everything and listen deeply – and seek help if needed.
8. Final Thought: Be the Counter‑System Your Child Can Trust
The grading system is an unfair imaginary competition. It ranks children before they are adults and compares them as if they were identical units on a conveyor belt. You may not be able to change that system today. But you can decide what is true inside your home.
Your task is not to produce the “perfect student” for the machine. Your task is to raise a sane, grounded human being who knows:
- “I am more than my grades.”
- “I am not in a race against my classmates or my siblings.”
- “I have strengths the report card will never show.”
- “Even when I fail, I am still worthy of love and respect.”
#GradesDontDefineYou #ParentingInTheSystem #SchoolPressure #ChildrenAreMoreThanNumbers #EducationReform #MentalHealthForKids #AnthropologyOfEducation
Comments
Post a Comment
We invite you to comment, keep it respectful, you can also email: Clifford.illis@gmail.com